Ok, I hope this is the proper place to post this question. I am thinking of getting one of the two and would like to get everyone's input. Here are the brand and specs:
Giant Rincon $399:
Frame Giant ALUXX butted-aluminum
Fork SR SunTour XCM, 100mm-travel w/preload adjustment
Rims/Wheels Aluminum
Hubs Aluminum
Spokes 14G stainless-steel
Tires Kenda Front: Blue Groove 26 x 2.1, Rear: Nevegal 26 x2.1 (Anthracite/Black), Kenda K-Rad 26 x 2.1 (Olive/Black)
Crankset TruVativ Isoflow
Chainwheel 42/32/22
Front Derailleur Shimano Acera
Rear Derailleur Shimano Alivio
Rear Cogs SRAM, PG-830 8-speed: 11-32
Shifters Shimano EF-50
Handlebars Aluminum
Stem Aluminum
Brake Levers Shimano EF-50
Brakes Tektro IO mechanical discs
Pedals Aluminum platform
Saddle Unity Speed Groove (Anthracite/Black), Giant DJ (Olive/Black)
Seat Post Aluminum
Specialized Hardrock Sport $419:
Frame Specialized A1 Premium aluminum
Fork SR Suntour SF7-XCM, 100mm travel; 12-inch: 80mm travel
I dont know too much about the Giant, but I do have a 2005 Hard Rock Sport with Disc Brakes. I have had it for 3 1/2 years with no problems. I use mine as a daily rider as well as hiting the trails whenever possible. I have recently upgraded some of the components, but was very satisfied with the stock Hard Rock. I have talked to many people and they all agree that it is a great entry level bike as well as an all around bike as well.
Both are comparable bikes, as are most all manufacturers bikes at this price range. It is really a matter of how you feel when you sit on the bikes.
However, one of the biggest diffrences I see offhand is that the giant has disc whereas the hardrock has vbrakes. Those disc on the giant are horrible though, these low end mech disc arent worth having in my opinion. So you are left with the delima of buying and upgrading the disc on the giant for around a hundred or going with the hardrock and upgrading to some new brake pads for around twenty bucks.
However in my opinion the hardrock frame is much beefier and feels nicer on the trail than the rincon, having rode both.
Im hopeing your looking for 08 closeouts. The 09 hardrocks arnt nearly as well made as the 08's.
Thank you all for your replies. I test rode them and several others and decided on the Specialized. Spec4life, it is an 08 model.
I am looking forward to going for my first true ride in 20 years on Sunday morning. I am going to take it slow, as I notice I was not as good on a bike now, like I was 20 years ago
But, before you know it I will be hitting some trails.
Awesome man. In my personal opinion, though biased, its hard to beat the hardrock as an entry level bike...:thumbsup:
Heres mine as well as what Iv done to it. Check into these brake pads they make a huge difference.
08 Specialized Hardrock Sport
Upgrades:
Oury Mtn Grips
Kool Stop dual compound Mtn brake pads
WTB Velociraptor Kevlar tires Front and Back (back had to be sent back not pictured here)
Lizard Skins chainstay protector
Seat
Wellgo Platform Pedals
Awesome man. In my personal opinion, though biased, its hard to beat the hardrock as an entry level bike...:thumbsup:
Heres mine as well as what Iv done to it. Check into these brake pads they make a huge difference.
08 Specialized Hardrock Sport
Upgrades:
Oury Mtn Grips
Kool Stop dual compound Mtn brake pads
WTB Velociraptor Kevlar tires Front and Back (back had to be sent back not pictured here)
Lizard Skins chainstay protector
Seat
Wellgo Platform Pedals
I have a 09 Giant Rincon and i love it..its a good street crusing bike and a great trail bike.. Ive never rode a specialized hard rock tho.. but they seem nice 2..
I was in the same dilemma not to long ago as well. I ended getting an 08 Giant Rincon just because it had better components and it fit me a little better than the Specialized. Either way you can't really go wrong. I think the Specialized HR is lighter than the Giant (the Rincon is built like a tank), however Giant's geometries are a little more comfortable IMHO. The drivetrain components are a little better on the Giant and both stock forks just blow. Upgrade that first. I picked up a DART 3 on Ebay for $60.00. The disc brakes on the Giant aren't the best but they work. I'm not sure if the HR has disc ready wheels. Another option would be just to save a little more money and just get a full suspension bike. 2 months after I bought my Rincon I ended up building up a Marin Trail Attack.
ive got the 08 giant ricon and love it. the disc brakes work good for me, but then again i havnet had any others to compare them too.
I got my dad a HR, and its also a great bike, but i prefer the giant.
I have the 08 rincon, and just recently took a friend to buy his first bike where he faced the same situation you are (were) in.
Giant has one full step up in derailleurs, however these still suck as shimano derailleurs go.
Giant has so called "crappy disk brakes", however I have found that once I got them tuned just the way I like them (and take care of them), they work great.
The Spesh has pretty good Vbrakes, but has a 2 bolt stem, which personally, I dont like as much as the 4 bolt. Also, both forks are pretty cruddy, and weigh a lot, but the Giant has 100mm travel, vs 80 on the spesh.
They are very similar, but I honestly believe (though just a tad biased here) that the Giant is the better bike for the buck
However, my buddy ended up getting the 08 Cannondale F4, which trumps both bikes...go figure...
I I had the 08 Hardrock. Great solid bike, really light. I was riding circles around my buddy and his mongoose XR200. I had it for 3 months and just sold it and upgraded to a stumpjumper.
I truly appreciate all of the responses and had decided on the Hard rock. I have been riding it all week and I love it. The day after I purchased it I did a 16 mile ride and could not believe the smooth ride.
I have been riding it to work and plan on going to the beach tomorrow with it. I live apporx. 5 - 5 1/2 miles from the beach, so it will be an enjoyable ride.
wow this is just what I was needing. I'm debating on the same bikes same year. I seem ot be leaning on the rincon because of the disc brakes and upgraded derailleurs, but Idk. I guess all in all they are basically the same so it's all personal preference and what feels the best.
Awesome man. In my personal opinion, though biased, its hard to beat the hardrock as an entry level bike...:thumbsup:
Heres mine as well as what Iv done to it. Check into these brake pads they make a huge difference.
08 Specialized Hardrock Sport
Upgrades:
Oury Mtn Grips
Kool Stop dual compound Mtn brake pads
WTB Velociraptor Kevlar tires Front and Back (back had to be sent back not pictured here)
Lizard Skins chainstay protector
Seat
Wellgo Platform Pedals
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Mountain Bike Reviews Forum
15.4M posts
515.2K members
Since 1990
A forum community dedicated to Mountain Bike owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about bike parts, components, deals, performance, modifications, classifieds, trails, troubleshooting, maintenance, and more!