Does size really matter?

Printable View

  • 10-25-2012
    Blister Butt
    Size doesn't matter; color does!
    I've got bikes with 26" and 29" wheels. Each has their strengths and weaknesses. I now shop for bikes with two criteria (in order of importance):

    How's the fit?
    Do you love the color?

    Back to basics again I guess.

    Have fun and ride!
  • 10-25-2012
    Tystevens
    I had some good ol' fashion plain fun on my 26" wheels last Saturday. So I'm still on board.

    Related question -- does anyone here think that the difference between 26 and 29 might have been blown out of proportion somewhat? Like maybe the difference isn't THAT big? I mean, I've taken a couple laps on a 29'er (a good one, too -- a brand new '12 carbon Tallboy). It wasn't the most technical or intense terrain ever, but I put 3 or 4 miles on it, including a couple climbs, descents, and a couple quick rock gardens. Of course, the Enduro and the Tallboy are quite different bikes altogether, so it was hard to tell what was due to the wheels vs. all other aspects of the bike. But IMHO, the difference was more like vanilla vs vanilla bean ice cream, as opposed to vanilla vs chocolate like people try to make it out to be.

    Of course, there are those on MTBR that make a tubeless conversion seem like a huge change performance-wise. Where, for me, I couldn't hardly you the difference when I went from tubes to tubeless back to tube on the rear after I ripped up a sidewall. So maybe I just have an undistinguished pallet!
  • 10-25-2012
    FX4
    I guess my assessment is its easier to cover ground fast on the 29er. Acceleration seems slower. Not as much fun in the techy stuff. The 26" bike is more responsive, handles the techy stuff better but will not clean as large of objects as well as the 29er. When I go XC riding with a friend I grab the 29er, when I go mountain biking I grab the 26er. It's just more fun to ride. I guess when push comes to shove I really don't care for the wagon wheels all that much. I suppose if you are racing they are an advantage for most guys.
  • 10-25-2012
    FujNoob
    I still can't figure out why one would care what others thought of their wheel size choice. All that matter is that you like what you ride.
  • 10-25-2012
    FX4
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by FujNoob View Post
    I still can't figure out why one would care what others thought of their wheel size choice. All that matter is that you like what you ride.

    I wonder about that too. It's what you like that matters. Not anybody else.
  • 10-25-2012
    mudhen
    I have an old Trek 820 that is a blast to ride. Probably won't sell it, no reason to give it away for what someone would pay for it today.

    But, I am totally sold on 29'ers, and just love long rides on my Carve in the country, roads, trails, whatever, the bike is just plain stupid fun!

    Very unlikely I'd go back to 26" anytime soon, too many 29'ers to buy first....

    mudhen
  • 10-25-2012
    Thor29
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by TrailNut View Post
    My guess is that many 29er are not riding the rough rocky descends, but I really do not know.

    Yes - you really do not know.

    I've ridden my 29ers at Northstar (lift served DH) and anywhere you can ride smaller wheels. The only real problem is that there is still a lack of heavy duty tires and longer travel forks for 29ers if you want to do downhill or freeride. Currently there is no problem at all with 29ers as all mountain or trail bikes - there are plenty of bikes in that category and plenty of us ripping it up on the most gnarly rocky downhills out there. If anything, that is where big wheels shine.
  • 10-25-2012
    scrublover
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by FujNoob View Post
    I still can't figure out why one would care what others thought of their wheel size choice. All that matter is that you like what you ride.

    This.
  • 10-25-2012
    Tystevens
    Here is an interesting article asking some of the top designers in the mtb industry about wheel size and their plans for the future.

    The Future of 27.5 and 650b Mountain Bike Wheels | Bicycling Magazine

    Particularly interesting what Dave Turner says about 27.5 eventually killing off the 26" wheel (see page 3).
  • 10-25-2012
    OscarW
    I sold my Epic 29r in favor of my Blur LT... Not that the 29r is a bad bike/ride ,but just not for me. The 650 appeals to me more, specially for the type of trails I ride. YMMV
  • 10-25-2012
    Millfox
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Tone's View Post
    Its always good to have a sister to get some early practice in with,:skep: i did and now im married to her with 3 kids, the kids have a few inbred traits and deformities, but they will get over it....:thumbsup:

    Oh lol It didn't occurred to me that someone might of take it THAT way... Um... we were more like talking about it when I was going for my... I wanted to know what she thought she had more experience... I mean not too much experience... eh.. DONT JUDGE ME!
  • 10-25-2012
    kjlued
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Tone's View Post
    Ive heard plenty say it, in fact a member here that rides xc comps on a 29er said to me a week ago that he was really looking forward to buying a new 26er, as he was missing the fun he had on his :thumbsup:

    I am sure plenty do, I am just saying that I have not heard anyone say they would rather have a 26er.

    I have heard a few people say they want 650b.....but they were all on 26ers also.

    I know it all comes down to riding preference.
    That being said, buy what feels good to you and don't let anyone tell you what you should ride.
  • 10-25-2012
    lidarman
    What really matters is having too large a package on the saddle on large rides! ;)
  • 10-25-2012
    kjlued
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by lidarman View Post
    What really matters is having too large a package on the saddle on large rides! ;)

    Good thing you don't have to worry about that. :p
  • 10-25-2012
    Bikesrock
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by rayzer View Post
    Anybody out there still think that 26" wheels are still the way to go for just plain fun?

    29er bikes are defiantly the race choice but if you are a aggressive style rider then 26er is the way to go. 26er bikes are just plain easyer to handle and can be a lot more durable in all mountain bikes.
  • 10-25-2012
    Hollyw00d
    Having ridden both, I prefer 26". I feel like they're more playful, and I'm not a big guy 5'7" 175, so 29" feels too big for my liking...

    So for me 26" all day. my commuter is a 26" as well and I like it.
  • 10-25-2012
    jhazard
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Blister Butt View Post
    I've got bikes with 26" and 29" wheels. Each has their strengths and weaknesses. I now shop for bikes with two criteria (in order of importance):

    How's the fit?
    Do you love the color?

    Back to basics again I guess.

    Have fun and ride!

    yep, pretty much this. No need to debate, go ride A bike... :thumbsup:
  • 10-25-2012
    Hollyw00d
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by jhazard View Post
    go ride A bike... :thumbsup:

    This!! I'm on a 48hr shift and can't ride.... :(

    Can't wait to get home and ride.
  • 10-25-2012
    Gordon Shumway
    You say potato, I say tomato.. Wait.. Just go f-ing ride and have fun!
  • 10-25-2012
    ElwoodT
    I have two 29er's that I love just about equally. (rigid ss, and 1x9 ht) My next bike will likely be 26fs.
  • 10-25-2012
    col200
    I'm a big guy (200 lbs, 6'2") and own both a 26" HT and a 29" HT rigid. They're definitely different beasts but both are fun as hell. Honestly, I'm keeping my 29er SS rigid because I don't think the geometry would be as fun to chuck around than my 26er.
    It's kinda funny to see how many 29ers I see at the trail. I feel old-school sometimes when I ride my brand new On-one 456Evo.:D

    I just ordered a 26er fatbike. :thumbsup:
  • 10-25-2012
    rotten1
    My next bike will be...

    A bike.
  • 10-25-2012
    tg
    Love my Satori but on race day I go with my Turner Flux....I am just old I guess...Both bikes are fun and have a place to shine.
  • 10-25-2012
    Gordon Shumway
    I love lamp.
  • 10-25-2012
    bmf032
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Tystevens View Post
    I had some good ol' fashion plain fun on my 26" wheels last Saturday. So I'm still on board.

    Related question -- does anyone here think that the difference between 26 and 29 might have been blown out of proportion somewhat? Like maybe the difference isn't THAT big? I mean, I've taken a couple laps on a 29'er (a good one, too -- a brand new '12 carbon Tallboy). It wasn't the most technical or intense terrain ever, but I put 3 or 4 miles on it, including a couple climbs, descents, and a couple quick rock gardens. Of course, the Enduro and the Tallboy are quite different bikes altogether, so it was hard to tell what was due to the wheels vs. all other aspects of the bike. But IMHO, the difference was more like vanilla vs vanilla bean ice cream, as opposed to vanilla vs chocolate like people try to make it out to be.

    Of course, there are those on MTBR that make a tubeless conversion seem like a huge change performance-wise. Where, for me, I couldn't hardly you the difference when I went from tubes to tubeless back to tube on the rear after I ripped up a sidewall. So maybe I just have an undistinguished pallet!

    AMEN! I own both and feel the same way.