2013 Camelbak MULE NV vs 2013 Osprey Raptor 14

[gundam]

I am trying to decide between a 2013 Camelbak MULE NV and a 2013 Osprey Raptor 14. I like the zipper on the hipbelt pockets and the two side pockets on the Raptor. But I prefer the MULE's rain cover over the Raptor's tool pouch. I also like the MULE's D-Fit suspension. I guess I will have to try them both out at a store too see how they fit me before I pull the trigger.

Any comments/suggestions?

[HouseNotes]

Here's a good article on both. Mountain Mileage: Hydration Pack Battle - Camelbak Mule vs. Osprey Raptor 14

Hope this helps. P.S. I have an older Mule and I bought the newer Osprey. Love it!

Update: the newest Raptor has zippers on the hip pockets. Now you won't lose whatever you put in there-car keys!

[Joules]

if you have a chance to try both on (with water in them) I doubt you'll ever buy another camelbak product again.

It's like the difference in comfort of carrying 30# in a school book bag vs a real backpacking pack. Yes, Osprey is that much better.

[HouseNotes]

+1 Osprey takes hydration packs to a whole new level.

[worrptangl]

I have the Raptor 10 and posted some thoughts a few threads down. Take a look if you get a chance. I love it!

[Porschefan]

I've had several Camelbaks: Mule, HAWG NV and the Charge LR. All are, or were, 2010-11 models. I still have the Charge LR, which is an ultralight pack for short rides with the reservoir in the belt (hence "Lumbar Reservoir).

I also have had an Osprey Manta, which I really liked and still have an Osprey Stratos 36, which is a GREAT day-hiking pack and will even work OK on a bike. I think the new Osprey Raptor 10 would be my choice. I just think that Osprey's overall design and quality are superior. And the new 2013 Raptor's with the tool belt will be my next bike pack. My .02!

[HouseNotes]

This might be helpful in making your decision.

Post a review get rep 3" larger! and Prizes too!

[gundam]

Thanks for all the input. I have decided on the Raptor 14.

[HouseNotes]

Good choice. I think you'll be very happy.