Quote:
Originally Posted by Porschefan
I'm a newb and have been in the market for a dropper seatpost and I have a beginner's question. What is the purpose of having a super-long drop? If I understand things correctly, about the maxium drop my bike could handle is 5-in./125 mm. Kind Shock has a 6" model, but if I put that on my bike the seat would be too high at maximum extention. I've seen the RASE and would consider this new one, but I don't understand how more drop could be of any use?
|
Many seatposts have a minimum amount of exposed seatpost needed for a given amount of drop- so most of the time you'll always have 3 inches exposed.
You'll have to determine you seatpost diameter and then look at the various options out there to see what max drop you can get with only a 5 inch exposed seatpost.
The RASE looks really good because it fits a 27.2mm seatpost and offers max drop. There aren't currently many options for those of us with 27.2mm seatposts.
The RASE is also mechanical (springs) as opposed to hydraulic (air or oil). KindShocks just came out with a hydraulic 27.2mm with an oil reservoir.
For me personally, since I have a 27.2 mm. I've only got a few options:
Gravity Dropper- only offers 3" of drop for the exposed 6.5" of seatpost I run.
RASE- Gives me the full 6.5" of drop (maybe a little less because the sock will bunch up).
KindShocks Super Natural 272- offers 4" of drop. From the threads I have seen as of late KS is having customer service issues. This is also a new system, it is hard to find, and people don't have a lot of experience with it. It is also hard to tell how much exposed seat post is needed for the 4".
For me the RASE seems like the clear winner and since Austin (the designer) is working on a new build that should be ready in the next couple of months- I'm just going to wait.
If you have a larger diameter seatpost you have way more options. The Specialized Command Post is supposed to be good. Giant just came out with a new one. Crank Bros' one has always had horrible reliability issues but rumor is that they are getting better. and there are the options I listed above that are available in larger sizes stock or with a shim.