ok it's time to order a new shock for the XVP ... ( the 5th dim rebound control died and now rebounds almost like an ejector seat)

1) I could order the Fox RP23, ok shock have one on my other bike but always been disappointed that I can't tell much difference in the 3 different pro pedal settings

2) I could get an RL, has a pro pedal setting and a full lockout setting, full lockout may be more useful than the 3 pro settings on the occasional smooth fireroad?

3) I have a Rockshox Reba team with lockout fork, great fork ... should I be getting a Rockshox Monarch shock??

thanks for any feedback