Looking at Possibly a Roscoe or Remedy to replace my 08 CD Prophet 1. Either will have a far better working rear suspension than my single pivot Prophet I would hope.

The more simple Roscoe design appeals to me coming from the single pivot of the Prophet but the Full Floater design of the Trek has just wonderful reviews. I'm tired of getting hammered on the Prophet with lack of small bump compliance and want a REALLY good rear suspension for the rocky, rooty conditions I ride in.

Any thoughts and who has ridden both? Remedy at 150mm travel is a tiny bonus. Both bikes have 68* HA. Roscoe does look Bad Ass for sure but better bike is more important.