Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 100 of 309
  1. #1
    wounded knee
    Reputation: dirtrider6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,368

    Pugsley frame failure

    I know I seen a thread on this a while back I have searched in vain and found nothing.
    About 2 weeks ago I had a frame failure on my 2010 Surly Pugsley, behind the seat stay right where the failures were on the 2012 if I remember correctly.



    My local shop Valley Cycles was nice enough to take care of all the Warranty paperwork and headaches that go along with it for me.

    They got the ok to send it back but no call tag, and when they asked for one there was no reply? So I'm going to have to foot the bill for shipping which acording to them is not the norm.

    Anyone else that went through this how long did it take to get the new frame?
    Did you pay shipping?
    I know I'm going to have to pay the shop for switching all the parts over, honestly I just want my favorite bike back in time for Winter.
    Sponsored by
    VETTA
    GoPro HD Hero Camera
    The Recovery Sock

  2. #2
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    2,251
    I was looking for that old thread too, no idea what happened to it. Surly should take care of the shipping, they are usually really good with warranty issues. Have your LBS call them again tomorrow for a call tag. Your LBS will have to pack the frame to send back to Surly on their own dime, so I'd recommend dropping off a 12 pack of beer shortly before closing
    Jason
    Disclaimer: www.paramountsports.net

  3. #3
    mtbr member
    Reputation: pbasinger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    746
    Iíve had several frames from small builders and big manufactures break over the years and warrantied many customer frames. Iíd say itís about 50/ 50 when it comes to manufacturers paying for the return shipping. Itís always worth having your shop ask, but jeeze, youíve got a few seasons of riding on this thing, $35 to get a new frame is a pretty sweet deal if you ask me. As long as it is warranty, and they have a frame in your size in stock, I bet youíll have a
    shiny new frame by the end of the week.

  4. #4
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Yoreskillz's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Posts
    297
    LBS took in my damaged frame (7 months of riding on mine before I noticed the cracks) and received a warranty frame from Surly. There was some arm wrestling over who was to pay for shipping to an fro but between them but I was not involved in that. Also said bike shop was under new ownership after I purchased my Pugsley, so the frame/parts swap was on my dime albeit discounted. I like Surly and the bike shop so I paid the bill and went for a ride! No harm, no foul.

  5. #5
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    Quote Originally Posted by Yoreskillz View Post
    LBS took in my damaged frame (7 months of riding on mine before I noticed the cracks) and received a warranty frame from Surly. There was some arm wrestling over who was to pay for shipping to an fro but between them but I was not involved in that. Also said bike shop was under new ownership after I purchased my Pugsley, so the frame/parts swap was on my dime albeit discounted. I like Surly and the bike shop so I paid the bill and went for a ride! No harm, no foul.
    this seems reasonable

  6. #6
    wounded knee
    Reputation: dirtrider6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,368
    Honestly I don'y mind paying the freight out $56.00, and the changeover of parts from my LBS, I also have them regreasing all the bearings, running all new cables, ect.
    I have had 2 and a half years of riding my favorite mountain bike, I just hope to hear something next week about when I'll see the new frame.
    Sponsored by
    VETTA
    GoPro HD Hero Camera
    The Recovery Sock

  7. #7
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    ^Cheers for positive news

  8. #8
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    251

    Sorry to hear that...are u getting the yellow or red frame

    or do they have white frames still in stock?
    Your pugs was the bike that convinced me that I had to get a fat bike. Rode it briefly at the moon over a year ago. Surprised to see the frame crack, that bike seemed like a tank!!!!

  9. #9
    wounded knee
    Reputation: dirtrider6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,368
    Quote Originally Posted by Team Honeybadger View Post
    or do they have white frames still in stock?
    Your pugs was the bike that convinced me that I had to get a fat bike. Rode it briefly at the moon over a year ago. Surprised to see the frame crack, that bike seemed like a tank!!!!
    I wish they had the white, from what I hear I'm getting a Yellow frame, would of rathered the Red, maybe it's time for a change though, can't wait to get it back.
    I'm allways happy to let people ride it, love hearing them say WOW I thought it would be slow and cumbersome, and see the reaction on their faces.
    Sponsored by
    VETTA
    GoPro HD Hero Camera
    The Recovery Sock

  10. #10
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    THere are more than a handful of unique reports of the OP's type of failure on the Amazing Surly Pugsley Facebook page... not good..

  11. #11
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    697
    Local guy had this happen on 3 white frames in a fairly short amount of time. The first one after a year or so, and the others a few months afterwards for each. His yellow one is holding up good so far. The design of the rear seat stay is different on the new yellow frame. He's not riding it super hard, sand rides and single track with no hucking off of big drops or anything.

  12. #12
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Velobike's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    6,529
    Quote Originally Posted by sfuller View Post
    Local guy had this happen on 3 white frames in a fairly short amount of time...
    Is the frame is on the small side for him and he's using a longer seatpost to make up for it? (ie insertion depth insufficient). Or is he using a stiff seatpost?

    This is happening often enough that Surly need to reinforce that area to make it foolproof.

    This sort of problem plagues manufacturers of well-used folding bikes which tend to use long seatposts (although most don't get ridden far enough for this to become evident)
    As little bike as possible, as silent as possible.
    Latitude: 57ļ36' Highlands, Scotland

  13. #13
    wounded knee
    Reputation: dirtrider6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,368
    The good news is my replacement frame should be here by Friday, the bad news is it might be a White one, I don't understand why they would still be shipping these frames out for replacement ones when they know there is a problem with them, I'm going to be inspecting it every ride.
    Sponsored by
    VETTA
    GoPro HD Hero Camera
    The Recovery Sock

  14. #14
    mtbr member
    Reputation: RockyRider's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    822
    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    THere are more than a handful of unique reports of the OP's type of failure on the Amazing Surly Pugsley Facebook page... not good..
    Yeah I saw that. Also a lot of assumptions being made there about what the cause is that are pretty far fetched.

  15. #15
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    if they changed the design on the yellow and red frames, safe to say the Necro pug has the same design as the white? and potentially same issue?

  16. #16
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    268
    I can't visualize how the forces work. Could someone explain how the curved piece as opposed to the straight piece makes the frame crack?

  17. #17
    middle ring single track
    Reputation: Moe Ped's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    3,656

    Pictures?

    Quote Originally Posted by kuan View Post
    I can't visualize how the forces work. Could someone explain how the curved piece as opposed to the straight piece makes the frame crack?
    I'm not sure exactly what part you're referring to but all other things being equal a curved piece is more flexible than a straight one. Often used by designers to give a frame "compliance" (makes it ride softer)

    If you're talking about the strut between the seatstays (curved on my Pugs) a curved one will allow more flexing where the seatstays join the seat tube (where those cracks are) than a straight one.

    Designs need to be flexible, the trick is spreading the flexibility around so a single area is not overloaded. (beyond the material's fatigue limit) A straight strut might just move the cracking failures to another area.

    I wonder if the cracked frames are being ridden hard? (jumps, wheelies, hammered?)
    Content here does not officially represent the CA DPR.

    Windows 10, destroying humanity one upgrade at a time.

  18. #18
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    268
    Ah I see. Makes perfect sense now. It's too flexy and the welds take the brunt of it, not the tubing. Thanks.

  19. #19
    middle ring single track
    Reputation: Moe Ped's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    3,656

    Haz...?

    It is worthwhile to note that it is not the weld bead itself that is cracked; it's in the seat tube immediately adjacent to the weld---this is a typical weld failure in the "Heat Affected Zone". This could be the result of poor weld technique, wrong materials or skipping possible post-welding heat treatment (normalizing); not necessarily poor geometry/design.

    My "Curry Squirt" Pugs (no cracks thus far) has much smaller weld beads in the area shown in the OP photo; this may be of some significance. I also noticed that on the red frame (still has a curved brace) pictured on the Surly site the tubes are now spaced further apart so the joints are more on the side of the seat tube.
    Content here does not officially represent the CA DPR.

    Windows 10, destroying humanity one upgrade at a time.

  20. #20
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Posts
    28
    Quote Originally Posted by dirtrider6 View Post
    The good news is my replacement frame should be here by Friday, the bad news is it might be a White one, I don't understand why they would still be shipping these frames out for replacement ones when they know there is a problem with them, I'm going to be inspecting it every ride.
    I was just communicating with Surly about this problem and I think form a manufacturing point of view there is very few bikes that are failing in this model (white) to send out a different model.

    Most of the white ones (like mine) are fine and good bikes. I know of others that have this model and their bikes are OK. So it is just an anomaly. A pain that it has happen to some, like yourself and it did cause me to check my bike and contact Surly. The good news is that Surly is such a great company to deal with and that they take good care of there customer.

    I hope all goes well with your new frame and I will be watching mine more closely.

  21. #21
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Tripower's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Posts
    579
    Quote Originally Posted by pliebenberg View Post
    It is worthwhile to note that it is not the weld bead itself that is cracked; it's in the seat tube immediately adjacent to the weld---this is a typical weld failure in the "Heat Affected Zone". This could be the result of poor weld technique, wrong materials or skipping possible post-welding heat treatment (normalizing); not necessarily poor geometry/design.

    My "Curry Squirt" Pugs (no cracks thus far) has much smaller weld beads in the area shown in the OP photo; this may be of some significance. I also noticed that on the red frame (still has a curved brace) pictured on the Surly site the tubes are now spaced further apart so the joints are more on the side of the seat tube.
    ^^^
    Yep.

    Failure in the HAZ.

  22. #22
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    Lots of activities on the the amazing surly pugsley facebook page regarding the frame failure.. Pop corn time!

    Hpefully this wont degrade white pugs' resale value.. I have fatter bikes within my view

  23. #23
    mtbr member
    Reputation: RockyRider's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    822
    Quote Originally Posted by pliebenberg View Post
    It is worthwhile to note that it is not the weld bead itself that is cracked; it's in the seat tube immediately adjacent to the weld---this is a typical weld failure in the "Heat Affected Zone". This could be the result of poor weld technique, wrong materials or skipping possible post-welding heat treatment (normalizing); not necessarily poor geometry/design.

    My "Curry Squirt" Pugs (no cracks thus far) has much smaller weld beads in the area shown in the OP photo; this may be of some significance. I also noticed that on the red frame (still has a curved brace) pictured on the Surly site the tubes are now spaced further apart so the joints are more on the side of the seat tube.
    Bingo! My first gen Pug has no problems and most likely never will and it's curved. It's absolutely absurd to claim that is the issue when its just a QC issue with the welds. Lots of claims being made by non metallurgists and people who have never TIG welded 4130. I'm sure Surly will straighten it out and people should be going to them and/or their LBS about it.

  24. #24
    mtbr member
    Reputation: RockyRider's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    822
    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    Lots of activities on the the amazing surly pugsley facebook page regarding the frame failure.. Pop corn time!

    Hpefully this wont degrade white pugs' resale value.. I have fatter bikes within my view
    Mostly one persons crusade from what I can see, and he's barking up the wrong tree.

  25. #25
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Posts
    39
    I've recently bought a used Pugs frame which had a similar crack and then had it repaired. So if out of warranty it's still fixable. Now awaiting powder coat and build up.

    Pugsley frame failure-img_3600.jpg

    Pugsley frame failure-img_3603.jpg

  26. #26
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Velobike's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    6,529
    Quote Originally Posted by andyh2 View Post
    I've recently bought a used Pugs frame which had a similar crack and then had it repaired. So if out of warranty it's still fixable....
    That's the beauty of a steel frame. Just about any local metalworker can fix them.

    A crack is not the end of the world. Surly will honour their warranty, and if out of warranty, a fix is cheap enough.
    As little bike as possible, as silent as possible.
    Latitude: 57ļ36' Highlands, Scotland

  27. #27
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Skywalker22's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Posts
    138
    I'm on my second frame and it is also starting to crack!

  28. #28
    mtbr member
    Reputation: trail rida's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    117
    dang, saw this thread, went to check my 2011 white pugs... Cracked in the same spot. WTF

  29. #29
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Velobike's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    6,529
    Quote Originally Posted by trail rida View Post
    dang, saw this thread, went to check my 2011 white pugs... Cracked in the same spot. WTF
    Oops! I'd better go and check mine....
    As little bike as possible, as silent as possible.
    Latitude: 57ļ36' Highlands, Scotland

  30. #30
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Posts
    28
    Quote Originally Posted by trail rida View Post
    dang, saw this thread, went to check my 2011 white pugs... Cracked in the same spot. WTF
    I checked mine when this thread first came out. No problems at frame is holding up fine.

  31. #31
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    damn man! I know internet reports of issues is not representative of the true percentage.. but all things being equal, I don't see this type of reports of failures on other bikes.. therefore it surely it can't just be a fluke manufacturing defect...?

  32. #32
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    697
    Quote Originally Posted by Velobike View Post
    Is the frame is on the small side for him and he's using a longer seatpost to make up for it? (ie insertion depth insufficient). Or is he using a stiff seatpost?

    This is happening often enough that Surly need to reinforce that area to make it foolproof.

    This sort of problem plagues manufacturers of well-used folding bikes which tend to use long seatposts (although most don't get ridden far enough for this to become evident)
    Frame is the right size for him. He does use a Cane Creek Thudbuster on his bike, but it was inserted well into the seat tube (past the seat/top tube joint and well past the seat stays.

  33. #33
    middle ring single track
    Reputation: Moe Ped's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    3,656

    How much frame flex?

    This much:
    <iframe width="853" height="480" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/ry7diWP6hR8?rel=0" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
    Not exactly related to this frame cracking problem, I've converted my Pugs to belt drive. In the process it's become necessary to know how much the frame flexes. (To see if it was within the specifications for the Gates Carbon Drive system)

    The video shows me (at 200#) "hammering" (off the saddle) up a 20% grade. The gearing is 39/28 F/R and the cranks have 175mm arms.

    The video is inverted because that's how the GoPro was mounted as was the scale; it's also being played at 1/2 speed. If you can't see the scale plainly then you may want to watch the vid directly on YouTube with the setting on HD.

    The test set-up is a rigid aluminum bar attached in the vicinity of the Bottom Bracket (the chain guide lug) with the back end having a scale (from an old tape measure blade) fixed with 1/16" markings . Under this heavy pedaling the frame is flexing laterally about 1/4"; during "normal" riding it's still flexing about 1/16".

    I'm sort of getting away with the flexing in regards to the belt but I think it's more than Gates would approve.

    In regards to the cracking; it "is what it is"---if solely due to flexing I'd expect to be seeing failure more so at the chain-stay/BB juncture than at the lighter loaded seat-stay/ST juncture. I still suspect a failure in the fabrication process at the factory; not the design.
    Content here does not officially represent the CA DPR.

    Windows 10, destroying humanity one upgrade at a time.

  34. #34
    mtbr member
    Reputation: RockyRider's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    822
    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    damn man! I know internet reports of issues is not representative of the true percentage.. but all things being equal, I don't see this type of reports of failures on other bikes.. therefore it surely it can't just be a fluke manufacturing defect...?
    Sure it can. While I wouldn't normally preheat or need to stress relieve 4130 this thin if I was welding it, letting it cool too fast after welding (TIG) it then it would become exceptionally brittle right where it's failing.

    These are made in Taiwan right? Not at all out of the question to have a new guy make mistakes like this on a production line (cooling too fast, tungsten strikes, etc). It's not a design issue- its a QC issue and I am sure they will take care of it.

  35. #35
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Tripower's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Posts
    579

    Bummer, mine is cracked too!!!

    After reading this post, I decided to inspect my frame in the same area. Oh, crap, I think I have the start of a HAZ crack. I spot checked it with fluorescent penetrant and it bleeds back wipe after wipe. I guess I will continue to monitor it.
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails Pugsley frame failure-pugsley-frame-crack-1.jpg  


  36. #36
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    709
    Quote Originally Posted by RockyRider View Post
    Sure it can. While I wouldn't normally preheat or need to stress relieve 4130 this thin if I was welding it, letting it cool too fast after welding (TIG) it then it would become exceptionally brittle right where it's failing.

    These are made in Taiwan right? Not at all out of the question to have a new guy make mistakes like this on a production line (cooling too fast, tungsten strikes, etc). It's not a design issue- its a QC issue and I am sure they will take care of it.
    yeah, but if it was a QC issue, wouldn't it show up in random areas on the bikes?
    if a product fails in one spot every time, when there are welds all over the bike, what are the chances that it's from a fluke mistake welding?

    it's possible there are poor welds all over the bike, but this is the only area that is stressed enough to cause failure, but a good design would be able to handle a little variance in the weld process. If the welds were that bad on QC, it would be apparent elswhere.

    I think it is obvious there is either a weak spot in the basic design, or the tubing spec is too thin right there.

  37. #37
    mtbr member
    Reputation: RockyRider's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    822
    Quote Originally Posted by autodoctor911 View Post
    yeah, but if it was a QC issue, wouldn't it show up in random areas on the bikes?
    if a product fails in one spot every time, when there are welds all over the bike, what are the chances that it's from a fluke mistake welding?

    it's possible there are poor welds all over the bike, but this is the only area that is stressed enough to cause failure, but a good design would be able to handle a little variance in the weld process. If the welds were that bad on QC, it would be apparent elswhere.

    I think it is obvious there is either a weak spot in the basic design, or the tubing spec is too thin right there.
    Not if they are using the same assemblers as a multitude of other bike companies. Its an actual assembly line where they make different runs of bikes and chances are it's one person welding that area and then it moves onto somebody else to work on other areas.

  38. #38
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    hmm just checked out my bike again and under a bright LED light I can see a faint line, just like Tripower's pic, but much fainter.. Can't feel it yet with my nail.. I'll keep monitoring it but I assume it will develop into a crack..

  39. #39
    Ride da mOOn Moderator
    Reputation: NEPMTBA's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    8,269
    ^in reference to the green colored frame above^...
    ...a little brass and gas, a metal gusset, and splash of paint later, makes Happy Jack!

  40. #40
    wounded knee
    Reputation: dirtrider6's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    1,368
    Surly really did stand behind their product, in less than 2 weeks time I was once again riding my favorite bike this past weekend and had a blast riding it on some of the roughest trails around here, I will be keeping a better eye on it.
    Sponsored by
    VETTA
    GoPro HD Hero Camera
    The Recovery Sock

  41. #41
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    Quote Originally Posted by dirtrider6 View Post
    Surly really did stand behind their product, in less than 2 weeks time I was once again riding my favorite bike this past weekend and had a blast riding it on some of the roughest trails around here, I will be keeping a better eye on it.
    great to hear.

  42. #42
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    2,251
    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    hmm just checked out my bike again and under a bright LED light I can see a faint line, just like Tripower's pic, but much fainter.. Can't feel it yet with my nail.. I'll keep monitoring it but I assume it will develop into a crack..
    Mine is at the same stage, visible with light but tough to photograph. Not worried, I marked the ends with a sharpie, if it grows past the marks then I'll contact Surly. Chances are it's been like that for months and I never bothered to notice. Surly is good people, they'll take care of it. There have been no reports of complete separation, so it's not really a safety hazard. Minor inconvenience if anything, but I'd be lying if I said I wasn't excited to drink beer and rebuild my bike!
    Jason
    Disclaimer: www.paramountsports.net

  43. #43
    Nemophilist
    Reputation: TrailMaker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Posts
    1,873
    Hey;

    This is not an uncommon failure, and has been seen on many different bikes for many years. There could be a number of reasons for it, both contributory or direct. While it is true that these cracks are appearing in the HAZ, that is most likely only a contributing factor at best. If it happened on an entire sequential batch of frames, in a more consistent pattern, I would be more inclined to believe it was an issue. More than likely, it is not a result of that at all, since it is a fairly widespread failure type, and somewhat random.

    It is most likely from simple fatigue failure. That area sees a lot of stress; from the twisting motion demonstrated in the previous video, from direct compression loading when the rear tire hits a bump, and from seat post stresses. Since those loads cannot be absorbed by the seat tube in bending/twisting over a length of tube because it is directly opposed by the top tube, the stress is put into the material in a very localized fashion. The small stay size also further focuses the stress in a small area. That very particular spot just on either side of the weld bead is also the first portion of tube unsupported by the weld, and so will see magnified stresses.

    It is likely that a redesign of the angles of the tops of the stays, where and how the intersect the seat tube, and the placement and shape of the bridge would solve it.
    Most people ply the Well Trodden Path. A few seek a different way, and leave a Trail behind.
    - John Hajny, a.k.a. TrailMaker

  44. #44
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    What is the HAZ?

  45. #45
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Tripower's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Posts
    579

    Haz

    Heat Affected Zone

  46. #46
    middle ring single track
    Reputation: Moe Ped's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    3,656

    Somebody hazn't...

    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    What is the HAZ?
    ...been following this whole thread!!!

    A good description can be found here Heat Treated 4130 thanks to some race-car aficionados.
    Content here does not officially represent the CA DPR.

    Windows 10, destroying humanity one upgrade at a time.

  47. #47
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    1,134
    Well I read this thread and went out to the garage to check my frame and here is what I found:



    Now what? I'm contacting my LBS who I purchased the bike new from. Hopefully Surly will honor their manufacturer defects warranty. From what I've read, they seem to stand behind their stuff.
    Last edited by ultraspontane; 12-31-2012 at 02:26 AM.

  48. #48
    mtbr member
    Reputation: SteveRice's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Posts
    112
    Found the same crack on my white Pug. My shop and Surly are standing behind the product and I'll be back on a fat bike in a week or so.

  49. #49
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    40
    HAZ has been covered.. But one aspect of the weld is.. the weld bead itself is usually taller and wider hence stronger/ less ductile.

    This lessening of Ductilitiy can lead to failure just around the weld and is not caused by HAZ but from bad design (uneven stress load)or even a to large weld bead. These look like stress cracks.

    4130 does not like to have stress risers and the lack of ductility simply can cause a stress riser within the tubing itself.

  50. #50
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    36
    Quote Originally Posted by RockyRider View Post
    Yeah I saw that. Also a lot of assumptions being made there about what the cause is that are pretty far fetched.
    the reason is the assymetrical seat stays dont distribute the load eqaully, one is more curved than the other, thus one flexes more and the other remains more rigid

  51. #51
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    Quote Originally Posted by captbuck View Post
    the reason is the asymmetrical seat stays don't distribute the load equally, one is more curved than the other, thus one flexes more and the other remains more rigid
    specifically the DS seat stay being the curved for the offset and the NDS seat stay being the more rigid or straighter of the two taking the brunt of forces..........makes perfect sense to me as the pics I've seen here show the NDS seat stay having the cracks or at least the worse.
    "ORANGE IS THE NEW BLACK"

  52. #52
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    709
    Quote Originally Posted by captbuck View Post
    the reason is the assymetrical seat stays dont distribute the load eqaully, one is more curved than the other, thus one flexes more and the other remains more rigid
    yes, I think the load distribution is the main factor. The right side has the benefit of longer leverage between it and the tire center. Also the chainstay comes into the seat tube too close to the center. It would be stronger if it were more to the side, where the tubing wall is more in line with the load. I still wonder why only the white ones are doing it.

  53. #53
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Tripower's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Posts
    579
    Quote Originally Posted by autodoctor911 View Post
    yes, I think the load distribution is the main factor. The right side has the benefit of longer leverage between it and the tire center. Also the chainstay comes into the seat tube too close to the center. It would be stronger if it were more to the side, where the tubing wall is more in line with the load. I still wonder why only the white ones are doing it.
    It is possible the white color makes the cracks easier to see.

  54. #54
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    36
    Quote Originally Posted by autodoctor911 View Post
    yes, I think the load distribution is the main factor. The right side has the benefit of longer leverage between it and the tire center. Also the chainstay comes into the seat tube too close to the center. It would be stronger if it were more to the side, where the tubing wall is more in line with the load. I still wonder why only the white ones are doing it.


    this was after 2 months of riding

    apparantly the cracks do not discrimate

  55. #55
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    226
    Just checked my 2011 Pugsley and have the same crack. My local shop is contacting Surly to see what's up.

  56. #56
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    just a matter of time for mine i guess....
    "ORANGE IS THE NEW BLACK"

  57. #57
    mtbr member
    Reputation: vaultbrad's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Posts
    885
    What have been the sizes of the cracked frames? Does angle of contact between seat stay and seat tube have anything to do with it? Hoping my big old 22" pug will be ok. Will keep an eye on it anyway.

  58. #58
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    226
    Mine is an 18".

  59. #59
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    73
    Has anyone heard of other models of surly frames having similar issues, or is it just the Pugsley?

  60. #60
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Posts
    1,134
    Quote Originally Posted by captbuck View Post


    this was after 2 months of riding

    apparantly the cracks do not discrimate
    Damn! My LBS wants to replace my cracked white frame with a black one. What year was this frame?

  61. #61
    SS Rider
    Reputation: peanut09's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    207
    Quote Originally Posted by captbuck View Post
    this was after 2 months of riding

    apparantly the cracks do not discrimate
    What year and size is this frame?

  62. #62
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    118
    I heard about this issue on a snow ride Sturday morning, me and a buddy checked our white 2011 pugs's- both cracked, both sides.

    Dang, man. and I just picked up the brackets I designed to put a 2012 lefty on it. F!
    Believe in yourself? Well, of course. Just be aware that believing in myself has been the root cause of most of my injuries!

  63. #63
    SS Rider
    Reputation: peanut09's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    207
    Quote Originally Posted by Vibrato View Post
    I heard about this issue on a snow ride Sturday morning, me and a buddy checked our white 2011 pugs's- both cracked, both sides.

    Dang, man. and I just picked up the brackets I designed to put a 2012 lefty on it. F!
    Well go through Surly get your new frame and install the lefty... Unless you just want to give up on fatbiking then you could sell me your lefty setup I have a pug to install it on

  64. #64
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Fakie1999's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    910
    Just checked my 2012. I've had it for almost exactly a year, cracked. Any chance I can get a refund on the frame? I really would prefer a 9zero7 now haha.


  65. #65
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Posts
    831
    I was out for a ride today and while I was waiting for my companions after a downhill I decided to do an inspection. Sure enough, the crack is starting on mine as well. The picture doesn't show it well, but it is fairly noticeable in the daylight. It looks like the crack is rusty.

    I'm not going to rush for a replacement, I'll finish out this season on it and worry about it in the summer. Not too thrilled about getting a yellow or red frame, I like the white, and it matches my white bits.

    16" frame, plenty of seatpost, I weight a fatso like 145lbs. Got it 1 year ago and only ride it in the snow.
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails Pugsley frame failure-jan2012-096.jpg  


  66. #66
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    Such bs.. Ppl cant say this is due to some fluke qc issue.. Or that everyone with a crack is putting frame through unreasonable usage scenarios

  67. #67
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Fakie1999's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    910
    Quote Originally Posted by Kris View Post
    I'm not going to rush for a replacement, I'll finish out this season on it and worry about it in the summer. Not too thrilled about getting a yellow or red frame, I like the white, and it matches my white bits.
    Same here. I'm going to call the bike shop tomorrow and see what they say, but, I'm not in a hurry. I'll most likely sell the replacement frame, and get something lighter.

  68. #68
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    Quote Originally Posted by Kris View Post
    I was out for a ride today and while I was waiting for my companions after a downhill I decided to do an inspection. Sure enough, the crack is starting on mine as well. The picture doesn't show it well, but it is fairly noticeable in the daylight. It looks like the crack is rusty.

    I'm not going to rush for a replacement, I'll finish out this season on it and worry about it in the summer. Not too thrilled about getting a yellow or red frame, I like the white, and it matches my white bits.
    i too like the white and built mine accordingly.
    "ORANGE IS THE NEW BLACK"

  69. #69
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Ze_Zaskar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    858
    Are the 2013 red/yellow frames any different in that area's design?

  70. #70
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    Quote Originally Posted by Ze_Zaskar View Post
    Are the 2013 red/yellow frames any different in that area's design?
    yessir they are. the C stay tubes on both sides are attached to the sides of the seat tube as opposed to behind it AND with support from the TT .(see pic) question is will this elim the issue? time will tell for those that purchased them.
    "ORANGE IS THE NEW BLACK"

  71. #71
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    49
    does this crack issue have any "creaking" sound associated with it? I have a 2012 white pugs, but haven't checkd for the crack yet. it does sometimes have a creaking sound but i think it might he seat related. just a thought.

  72. #72
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Fakie1999's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    910
    Quote Originally Posted by benswift View Post
    does this crack issue have any "creaking" sound associated with it? I have a 2012 white pugs, but haven't checkd for the crack yet. it does sometimes have a creaking sound but i think it might he seat related. just a thought.
    Mine doesnt creak at all.

  73. #73
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    70
    How about Moonlander frames? Any reports yet.
    Mine is still OK....after a half year of pretty hard use!

  74. #74
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    36
    Quote Originally Posted by ultraspontane View Post
    Damn! My LBS wants to replace my cracked white frame with a black one. What year was this frame?
    2012, and warrantied with another 2012. hope they fixed it for 2013 becuase imma ride the hell out of it and take back every cracked frame until the 3 year warranty runs out in 2015

  75. #75
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    36
    Quote Originally Posted by peanut09 View Post
    what year and size is this frame?
    2012, 18"

  76. #76
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Posts
    36
    Quote Originally Posted by benswift View Post
    does this crack issue have any "creaking" sound associated with it? I have a 2012 white pugs, but haven't checkd for the crack yet. it does sometimes have a creaking sound but i think it might he seat related. just a thought.
    yes, the tell tale creak is how I noticed it. 99% chances its not your seat, but your frame. took me a while to figure out where it was coming from, and intermittent like you are experiencing

  77. #77
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Posts
    831
    Quote Originally Posted by nvphatty View Post
    yessir they are. the C stay tubes on both sides are attached to the sides of the seat tube as opposed to behind it AND with support from the TT .(see pic) question is will this elim the issue? time will tell for those that purchased them.
    I ran into a buddy commuting to work this morning on his 2013 Necro Pug and mentioned to him the cracking issue. His 2013 Necro has the new frame design, same as the red and yellow. I'm sure Surly just has not updated their website photos to show the frame change on the Necro.

  78. #78
    Dirt Huffer
    Reputation: AC/BC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    1,641
    I'll buy anyones broken non-warrentied frame. PM me and ill give you a price. Looking for XS and L only

  79. #79
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    227
    Rode with a couple buddies this weekend that both have the 2012 pugs and we checked theirs and both of them had the cracks in the same spot. I got to looking at my 2012 Necro and it has a hairline crack started also.

  80. #80
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Ze_Zaskar's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    858
    Quote Originally Posted by nvphatty View Post
    yessir they are. the C stay tubes on both sides are attached to the sides of the seat tube as opposed to behind it AND with support from the TT .(see pic) question is will this elim the issue? time will tell for those that purchased them.
    Thanks
    Kind of glad I got a 2013 yellow frame

  81. #81
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    709
    Quote Originally Posted by Vibrato View Post
    I heard about this issue on a snow ride Sturday morning, me and a buddy checked our white 2011 pugs's- both cracked, both sides.

    Dang, man. and I just picked up the brackets I designed to put a 2012 lefty on it. F!
    What did you end up doing for the 2012 lefty?
    Are you cutting the old brackets completely off, leaving a straight tube, and using clamps like the older ones, or something different?

    If you don't mind sharing, I would love to do something like that with a 2012, or even a 2013 hybrid. I may just wait for the Supermax, which should have enough clearance without offset, but if you are doing something with the bonded/molded clamps, i may want to copy your design.

  82. #82
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    49
    checked mine- no crack. been riding it almost daily for almost 13 months.
    I'm fat too. I guess I got lucky.

  83. #83
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Posts
    29
    My 2011 looks OK. I am chubby, but have not pushed it too much.

  84. #84
    mtbr member
    Reputation: kreater's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    782
    Quote Originally Posted by Crafft View Post
    How about Moonlander frames? Any reports yet.
    Mine is still OK....after a half year of pretty hard use!

    i measured the tubing diameter on my moonie to a 2013 pugs and the seat stay tubes are larger on the moonie. don't know if this makes a difference. keeping an eye on mine.
    Product designer @RSDBikes.com

    "Live dangerously and you live right."
    Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

  85. #85
    mtbr member
    Reputation: kings23's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    12
    I went and checked my 2011 Pugsley last night and it seems to have the same issue.

    I've had my frame painted, does that void the warranty?
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails Pugsley frame failure-2013-01-07_17-30-36_482.jpg  


  86. #86
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Posts
    2,251
    Quote Originally Posted by kings23 View Post
    I went and checked my 2011 Pugsley last night and it seems to have the same issue.

    I've had my frame painted, does that void the warranty?
    You should be fine. See the information hole on the Surly website. If a repainted bike has a problem that also happens on stock bikes, they'll likely cover it.
    Jason
    Disclaimer: www.paramountsports.net

  87. #87
    mtbr member
    Reputation: Fakie1999's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    910
    My LBS said 2-3 weeks for my warranty frame. I'm gonna shop around and most likely pick up a new 9zero7 or fatback, then sell my pugsley after the warranty frame comes in. Good excuse to upgrade!

  88. #88
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    226
    Quote Originally Posted by bobkorn View Post
    Just checked my 2011 Pugsley and have the same crack. My local shop is contacting Surly to see what's up.
    Just heard from Surly and a new BLACK frame is on it's way. New frame design has different front derailleur mount so I have to replace with a direct mount front derailleur. Good reason for a little component upgrade.

  89. #89
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    Can u specify which color you want the replacement in?

  90. #90
    gone walk about
    Reputation: nvphatty's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    9,540
    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    Can u specify which color you want the replacement in?
    of the colors avail i believe so. I had a recent email exchange with surly regarding the failure and mentioned it was too bad they no longer have white as my build was based upon it. One could easily have any updated frame powder coated white then purchase a decal set which will be my path IF or when my frame fails.
    "ORANGE IS THE NEW BLACK"

  91. #91
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    226
    Quote Originally Posted by boogman View Post
    Can u specify which color you want the replacement in?
    I'm not a fan of the new colors so we asked for white or black and they had the black. It seems as if you just have to ask what's available.

  92. #92
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    226
    Took less than a week to get my replacement frame. Very happy with Surly and how they have handled everything.

  93. #93
    Puro Vida!
    Reputation: Nelson34's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Posts
    1,303
    I just checked mine prior to powder coating-nada

  94. #94
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Posts
    28
    Dang, I just checked my 18" thunderhead gray frame and there are two small cracks, one on each side. The cracks are so small and thin that If I hadn't broke out my night riding light and shined it on that exact spot, I would have never noticed. They look just like all the other scratches on the bike, except these ones follow the welds.

    I purchased from craigslist so no warranty for me. I should have never read this thread, now I will be inspecting the welds after every ride.

  95. #95
    mtbr member
    Reputation: vikb's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    9,935
    My two 2008 Pugs have being going strong, but I'll keep an eye on that area. No warranty so I'd just have to repair them myself.
    Safe riding,

    Vik
    www.vikapproved.com

  96. #96
    mtbr member
    Reputation: BoogieMang's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    286
    Quote Originally Posted by captbuck View Post
    yes, the tell tale creak is how I noticed it. 99% chances its not your seat, but your frame. took me a while to figure out where it was coming from, and intermittent like you are experiencing
    I have the creak, but no cracks... Probably just need to lube my seat tube.

  97. #97
    mtbr member
    Reputation: kyttyra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Posts
    187
    My 2012 Pugsley (ridden almost daily during those 9 months I've owned it) may have developed some cracks too. Can't say whether it's only the paint as there's no creak nor flex.



    The frame is 20" with 21 cm of seat post exposed and I'm a 76 kg pencil neck. Unfortunately, this is my only real winter bike (a fixed cx bike does not really count) and the local Surly retailer is on vacation until next week. I'll have to continue riding my Pugs until next week and keep my eye on the area.

    After all, a steel frame should not suffer a sudden&catastrophic failure, right
    Last edited by kyttyra; 01-22-2013 at 01:10 AM.

  98. #98
    mtbr member
    Reputation: jason-l's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Posts
    127
    Quote Originally Posted by kyttyra View Post
    My 2012 Pugsley (ridden almost daily during those 9 months I've owned it) may have developed some cracks too. Can't say whether it's only the paint as there's no creak nor flex.
    Sorry to see that. I'd say that if the powder coat has cracked then it's cracked for a reason... There has to have been movement of the frame material underneath to cause it.

  99. #99
    mtbr member
    Reputation: vikb's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    9,935
    Quote Originally Posted by kyttyra View Post
    My 2012 Pugsley (ridden almost daily during those 9 months I've owned it) may have developed some cracks too. Can't say whether it's only the paint as there's no creak nor flex.
    Sounds like you are still under warranty. I'd take it to your local Surly dealer or send Surly a photo so that you've identified the problem during the warranty period - even if you don't deal with it right away.
    Safe riding,

    Vik
    www.vikapproved.com

  100. #100
    mtbr member
    Reputation:
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    480
    ironic surly just came out with this blog post.. Blog | Surly Bikes

    i wonder if they qualify these cracks as "Certain things in this world need to be perfect to be enjoyed, but bicycles just ainít one of them."


Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast

Members who have read this thread: 6

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •