|
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
Comparison - Need people's opinions!
Hi there, I'm looking to buy an entry level freeride bike (around 180mm of travel, single crown forks). So far I've narrowed it down to 3: Ghost Northshore 2012, Scott Voltage FR 30 [2011/2012 model], Specialized Status I. Now initially i'd jump for the Status, but I've found the Ghost Northshore cheaper and the Voltage also seems very appealing, what does everyone else think?
Thanks
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
Note: The Specialized Status I i mentioned would be a 2012 model.
-
Uphill? What's that
Reputation:
Well here is my 2 cents.. Not a fan of Scott, I have never seen a Ghost bike so I can't comment on it. So that leaves the Status.. Good thing about the Status is you can throw a dual crown on it if you want.
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
yeah i guess that's true, i've heard good things about the scott voltages, and my friend has a ghost dh (the one up from the northshore) and swears by it, i'm just trying to find out if there's any problems with any of them i guess
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
The Voltage is extremely versatile with many different travel & geo adjustments and might be more affordable. You could potentially save money and upgrade key components like the fork or shock. I ride a Voltage FR20 mostly for DH purposes and only ride it in the 180mm travel mode with both DC fork and a single crown 180mm. It does just fine for me. The rear end is a little flexy, but depending on your weight it might not be that big of a deal; it doesn’t bother me. I like that you can build it up as a short travel jump bike or a 7” DH plower.
I have no experience on the Status or the Ghost.
Although the Status might be a little more DH oriented, it still seems like a pretty FR capable bike too. Proven FSR suspension over the Voltage’s single pivot. I like that the Status 1 is set up with more travel than the FR30 and I think the lower end X-fusion suspension on the Status might even be a little bit better than what’s on the FR30.
If I had the choice today, I might choose the Status over the Voltage.
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
ok thanks for the opinions, i'll still keep my eyes open. i think i'd rather have the status over the voltage, but the ghost seems really good and i've found a new one really cheap, i'll wait and see
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
Ghost.
You know the Germans always make good stuff.
-
 Originally Posted by pikls_94
ok thanks for the opinions, i'll still keep my eyes open. i think i'd rather have the status over the voltage, but the ghost seems really good and i've found a new one really cheap, i'll wait and see
I'd take the voltage over the Status anyday. The voltage feel a lot lighter, more playful, nimble, jump better and so on. The status is more of a DH rig, it will plow better and stuff, but I talked to a guy who rode one, and he said it jumped horribly, felt heavy and not nimble...
just my 2 cents
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
oh right that's interesting, i think i'd rather have a more playful nimble bike i guess, i think my friend's got a voltage actually, i'll have to ask if i can have a try, it does look more suited to what i want to do
-
Get a used Knolly Delirium frame (2010 or newer) and never look back! You can build one up for under what it would cost for one of the lesser bikes mentioned!
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
the Ghost bikes look amazing but i have never actually rid one. Scott is a fairly good company and a friend had a voltage and it was fairly durable. And with the specialized. My friend has a status 2 and absolutley loves it. rides really well.
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
overall i think the status.
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
-
Scratch That Itch
Reputation:
Trek Scratch is a nice bike in that range if you can find one on sale. I just bought mine and love it.
Trek Scratch 9 - Trek Bicycle Superstore San Diego CA
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
-
entry level bike?? so your first one and you are getting a 2012??? Don't do it....go a little older and save your cash....that way you can beat the bike up and then sale it for approx same price...then buy a better bike if you like the sport....again you would be stupid buying a 2012
the trick is ENJOYING YOUR LIFE EACH DAY, don't waste them away wishing for better days
-
mtbr member
Reputation:
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|