steel commuter frame
been commuting thru sf on my specialized allez to and from work, round trip is about 13 miles.
need a better commuting frame. can't mount any bag holders to front or back, i want a steel frame because on my allez i get bounced around a bit.
suggestions? ive seen soma and all city. looking for something similar to the space horse and mr pink. but somewhere in between...ideas?
Originally Posted by _dw
Take a look at the Surlys: LHT, crosscheck, straggler (crosscheck with disc). I think the Salsa casserole is kaput, but there's the vaya and possibly the fargo. Rawland is a personal fave. Tons of stuff out there. I also like the All City, especially the nature boy with the Hennepin ave bridge dropouts, but single speed of course.
I don't know why,... it's just MUSS easier to pedal than the other ones.
I love my Vaya. it's a great steel ride. I'm pretty sure it's going to be a bike that I keep for many years.
I bought a frameset and built it up myself, mostly with existing parts that came from a previous build.
Buy local..black mountain cycles
You have no excuse for driving to work
(unless you don't have studded tires)
(no excuse for that either)
I have a Chromag sakura, very springy and comfortable. Its like night and day compared to my old gt alu.
Originally Posted by EDizzleVR6
I have a banana under the seat bag, the biggest topeak xl there is. it lasted about 4 days with 2,5kg worth of locks in it. then the stitching broke on both straps. Had to make a sandwich of 2 alu plates, m6bolts, 5mm rubber sheets etc to make it durable. I lock it to the saddle with dual 8mm zipties and rubber sheets to prevent it from rattling (now when the outer surface is alu). I could probably put 10kg in there now and ride.
Rule #9 // If you are out riding in bad weather, it means you are a badass
Originally Posted by iheartbicycles
It might help if you'd elaborate on what you mean by "in between" here. Specifically, what are the qualities of Mr. Pink that you're looking for, because to me it seems like the Space Horse ought to be the better choice in nearly every way that they're different.
Originally Posted by EDizzleVR6
Reading between the lines, it sounds like maybe you want something that handles like a road bike but has the utility of a citified cyclocross-ish bike. Unfortunately, I think this isn't quite possible. For instance, just reading from the geometry chart, Mr. Pink is shooting for nimble handling with its short chain stays and steep (relative to the Space Horse) tube angles. That makes the bike fun, but the short chain stays lead to heel strike with rear panniers, and the steeper tube angles lead to toe overlap at low speeds, especially if you're using a front fender. So while you can imagine something like Mr. Pink with more tire clearance and braze-ons for racks, to make it practical you'd have to modify the geometry until it ended up looking like the Space Horse.
There are lots of nice steel frames out there, but to figure out which one is right for you you'll need to zero in on what specific qualities you're looking for.
BTW, I think getting "bounced around" is more a function of tire width than frame material.
The Fargo is a great commuter. Good riding position(s), comfortable and nearly limitless mounting points. You can vary the tires to meet your needs and the conditions. Planet bike fenders keep the muck coefficient down.
The most expensive bike in the world is still cheaper than the cheapest open heart surgery.
Since we're all in a love fest here... I love my steel Jamis (Coda, to be exact).
Pake C'Mute. Cheap, durable, does everything you want it to.
Take a look at touring frames, as well. Slacker geometry over the race-y bikes and longer wheelbase.
Surly - Cross-check, or LHT
Soma - Saga or Grand Randonneur
look at the specialized awol
Save a tree & wipe your butt with an owl.
Thank your local Sierra Club.
Im commuting on the new Vassago Fisticuff and very happy. Not as snappy as my carbon road bike, but SO smooth over rough city streets.
Recently Singlespeed-d it. Would like to do fenders and dynamo hub and permanent lights.
Raised in a Chicken-Coop by Chickens
By Tan&Green in forum The ReCycle Bin
Last Post: 06-15-2016, 11:24 AM
By briderdt in forum Frame Building
Last Post: 10-20-2013, 06:23 AM
By tangaroo in forum Bike and Frame discussion
Last Post: 09-24-2012, 05:56 PM
By MMcG in forum Commuting
Last Post: 03-15-2011, 07:39 AM
By swilln22 in forum 29er Bikes
Last Post: 03-10-2011, 07:25 AM