Still freakin thorn btween Small or Medium! This gonna be my do all bike! More trail.. thanx.. below some detail from a guy i my town who did a bike fitting ... I tot i spose to use Medium but then.....
Okay I've studies the measurements and done some calculations. I think a small will be bang on. Here is how I arrived at that conclusion:
-I drew the commencal frame geometry on my FrameCAD program then using your measurements made some rough (+/-5mm) calculations. With the small frame at the maximum seat height you will need to run, with the stock handlebar on the commencal should bring your seat level with the bar. Perfect for a mid travel bike. On the Med it has 10mm higher in the front and you dont need this height. You only need to go higher in head tube if the seat starts being way above the bar.
-Secondly while the commencal seems to have a shortish top tube remember the seat tube does not extend from the bb, it is in front of it AND at a 68 degree angle. As you put your seat to the right height and setback ,the seat is moving further back (due to the slack 68 angle) than what it would if the seat tube was the more standard 73/74 degree. This will have the effect of increasing the top tube length slightly more.
-I estimate you will need about 30cm of post/seat above the seat clamp on a small, that will equate to about 25cm of extension on the seatpost. Well within proportion.
-To run a XC style setup I think you will need a 100mm stem although this will not make use of the full capabilities of this bike ie. high speed manoeuvrability, ability to jump etc. Running an 70/80mm stem (depending on handlebar sweep and rotation) will bring you bang on the mark for enough weight over the front to climb satisfactorily but short enough to keep centre of gravity back for jumping, descending
-Yes you could ride a Medium frame and if you wanted to run a regular XC setup and put on a flat bar etc it would be okay. But there is no reason based on geometry or your measurements to require the bigger frame. The smaller frame will handle quicker due to the shorter wheelbase and I think a more versatile bike for the type of riding you are wanting to do.
-When I got my Meta 666 I got it for an XC type setup and bought a large, it was the right decision. The first commencal I got was a supreme mini dh and I got a med as it was for more dh tracks, freeriding etc. This was the right decision in both cases
Please Helpo!! Thanx
Mtbr's 2016 Winter Biking GearReviews and Roundups
Results 1 to 4 of 4