Anyone have experience with both Big Apples and Hookworms?
I am finalizing the build for my Big Dummy at the LBS this evening. I can't decide whether to try Hookworms or go with another set of Big Apples (I have them on my Ogre) because I know how they are and like them well enough.
The rims will be some to-be-picked-by-my-LBS-owner (who is into DH) DH rims that are on the wider side of things without going Large Marge, so maybe 35-36mm?
It will be ran primarily on road but a fair amount of gravel. Basically, nothing the Big Apple couldn't handle, I'm just wondering how the Hookworm is from a comfort standpoint.
Yes. I first rode the 2.0" Big Apples on my Big Dummy for about 100 miles, then switched to the 2.5" Hookworms. Glad I did. I found that the bike felt like it was understeering all the time until I switched to the Hookworms. Hundreds of miles later I am glad I made the switch. The Big Apples eventually found themselves on my Surly 1x1 for some 44x20 SS road riding, where they felt more at home than on a cargobike. The Hookworms are much more confidence-inspiring on marginal traction surfaces (wet, puddles, mud, gravel, etc.).
QUOTE from MTBR.COM: You have given out too much Reputation in the last 24 hours, try again later.
Hookworms are certainly heavier duty tires, the sidewalls on the BA's are pretty thin to help with ride quality. I really do like my BA's a lot but my next tires will likely be holy rollers for a little more grip offroad but to answer your specific question I would buy the hookworms.
...a wiggle theres a way
I have been using hookworms on the big dummy since April. I've logged about 3200 miles on them. Most of these have been commuting miles(80%). The other 20% have been hauling groceries, doing weekend tours, taking my other bikes to the shop, and also taking bikes and race supplies to my friends to take to a race.
Overall i'm very impressed with this tire it rolls quickly, grips well, inspires confidence going up and especially coming down canyons loaded with tour gear, it also wears slowly with a rotation every few months.So far no flats from nails, glass or goat heads. (i did have a tube blow out. The cause of that was an old tube that had been patched 4 times)
In short, I'd buy the hookworms again and would recommend them to you!
for completeness the tires the hookworms replaced were FatFranks
I have used both, and I find that the big apples are significantly faster rolling. I also found the hookworms were more round and they are less prone to speed wobble on my CETMA. Although I own both, the big apples are what are on my bike now.
For what it's worth, I like the Marathon Supremes even better, but they do not come in a 20 inch, nor are they as wide as the big apple 2.35"